I Am Legend

As you might have gleaned on your own from my Batman review, a lot of how I judge a movie depends on the context I'm watching it in. I think that's especially apparent in this movie, which sounds a little better in review than it really is. It's just solid craftsmanship, and there's something to be said for that.
---

So, right up front, full disclosure; I haven't read the book. My understanding is that it's "better" and has a "very different" ending. And that they moved it to new york city from russia, and made the white, Russian guy into Will Smith, then added something about Bob Marley. Okay, fine. I understand, it's not as good as the book. Now, not giving half a thought to the book, or to high art, but just to seeing a good Movie, I can watch the movie and enjoy it. And I did.

It's nothing special. Will Smith fights zombies as the presumed "last man on earth". It's an unabashed shock thriller with things-that-go-bump-in-the-night. But the catch is this-- Will Smith is really good. I'm not a big Will Smith fan (I liked Ali, haven't seen pursuit of happiness, and hated Hitch), but this is right up his alley and he nails it. He's calm, cold, and calculating, as well as frightened, guilt-ridden and desperate. And, god help me, I'm a sucker for Dogs, and the dog in this movie is amazing. Definitely the best guy-and-a-dog movie ever.

I liked the ending. It's a little predictable, in terms of what actually happens to Will Smith and the world. But, the thing with the body in the ice, while a little obvious in hindsight, was subtle enough. The other scenes with the body were justified on their own, in addition to contributing to the end. And, while the Butterfly thing at the end is the kind of thing I'd usually find schticky, it was, again, subtly planted in the movie to feel natural, but not look obvious.

Yes, it's pure Hollywood, but that's the mentality you should take into this movie: It's a glitzy horror/adventure story starring the world's biggest movie star, in terms of box office appeal, and they spent a ton of cash making it look good. And then, surprise, it's got a heart. It's got depth of emotion. It's got a dog, and the dog is fucking awesome.

Scores:
Directing: 7/10 (IMO, when you don't notice the director, he's doing a good job)
Writing: 7/10
Will Smith: 7.5/10
Dog: 10/10
Bob Marley: 4/20

Overall (not an average): 7/10